Friday, September 24, 2021

Why Did Jesus Call a Despised Man, Matthew the Tax Collector, and a Feared Man, Paul the Persecutor?

 The first batch of Jesus’ direct disciples were fishermen from Galilee: Peter (Simon), Andrew (Peter’s brother), James, and John (James’ brother)(e.g. Matthew 4:18-22). By the time he sent his disciples on mission, giving his authority and instruction, the number of Jesus’ disciples grew up to 12 (Matthew 10:1-42). And Jesus needed at least as many disciples as the twelve because “harvest is plentiful but the workers are few”, responding to the increasing pastoral needs (Matthew 9:37-38).

As the canonical Scriptures describes nothing about each of the twelve disciples’ background, except for the first four: Peter, Andrew, James, and John, all of whom were fishermen, and Matthew, who was a tax collector. Though we cannot pinpoint if Matthew was the twelfth disciples to be recruited by Jesus, based on the Scripture, it is likely that he was brought into the group of the disciples much later, compared to the other ones.

During the time of Jesus, as you can see in the Gospel narratives, tax collectors were despised figures among the Jews. They were also Jews. But, they collected taxes for the Roman Empire and often collect more than they had to – to fatten their personal and family coffers. Because of this, tax collectors were regarded as “traitors” and “unclean” among the Jews during the time of Jesus. And nobody wanted to be friends with them. They were not allowed to enter the Temple and synagogues to worship with other Jews. Though they could have enjoyed steady income, guaranteed by the powerful Roman government, and wealth built on cheating, tax collectors were ostracized, marginalized, and rejected by fellow Jews.

And, Jesus reached out to a tax collector, named, Matthew (Levi), and called him to follow him. And Matthew, without hesitation, just followed Jesus on the spot, and hosted a dinner for him (e.g. Matthew 9:9-13). But, who else were at this dinner in Matthew’s house – besides Jesus and possibly his disciples? Tax collectors and “sinners (Matthew 9:10). In other words, those who were at dinner with Jesus in Matthew house were those who were outcast, rejected, despised, and marginalized.


So there is a burning question: Why did Jesus bring in a despised and “unclean” man, Matthew (Levi) the tax collector to his “herd”?

A subsequent question can be: Didn’t Jesus worry that bringing Matthew could disturb peace among his “heard”, as the rest of the disciples sure hated tax collectors?

Sure, you can imagine how Peter and the rest of the disciples, who had been with Jesus, reacted to Matthew being brought into the community of the disciples. It was not easy and welcoming that they had to accept Matthew, who had been a tax collector. Who knows, Matthew and his tax collector colleague could have harassed some of the disciples in demanding more tax payments than they needed to collect. If this were the case, they could held grudge against Mathew and wanted to beat him.

Fortunately, the Gospel narratives have no remarks on the disciples trying to bully Matthew or asking Jesus to remove him out of the community of the disciples. Though it was not easy for them to have a former tax collector joining on the “team”, it seemed that they were able to accept Matthew as a “new comer” with a “unique background”.

Perhaps, what was more striking about bringing in a person with a very “unique background” to the pack was Jesus in spirit calling Paul (Saul) to join the already established apostolic team (Acts 9:1-30; cf. 1 Corinthians 15:8-11). And, at first, Ananias was called by Jesus in spirit to take care of Paul (Acts 9:10-12), but he did not seem happy about his assignment to care for Paul, as these words of Ananias indicate so:

Lord, I have heard from many sources about this man, what evil things he has done to your holy one in Jerusalem. And here he has authority from the chief priests to imprison all who call upon your name (Acts 9:13-14).

So, you can imagine, perhaps, one of the disciples could have said to Jesus, as he called and brought Matthew in:

Lord, you know and we know enough about this man and his colleagues, as well as, all evil things he has done on us for Caesar. He was given authority by the Romans to make us miserable for taxes for Caesar. Why are you letting him join us?

In response to Ananias’ concern about Paul, Jesus in spirit answered in these words:

Go, for this man is a chosen instrument of mine to carry my name before Gentiles, kings, and Israelites, and I will show him what he will have to suffer for my name (Acts 9:15-16).

So, Ananias did as Jesus in spirit commanded him to do. So Paul was baptized by Ananias and began preaching on Jesus in Damascus, where he was originally to “hunt” followers of Jesus’ way, and eventually came to the apostolic community in Jerusalem (Acts 9:17-25).

So, was Paul welcomed as a new member to the apostolic community in Jerusalem?

No. As a matter of fact, the rest of the apostles were afraid of Paul and did not believe him as an apostle, when he tried to join them in Jerusalem (Acts 9:26). But, Barnabas advocated for Paul to the apostolic community, explaining how he was converted on his way to Damascus and how he changed and began preaching (Acts 9:27). But it is hard to say if the apostolic community fully accepted Paul just because Barnabas assured that it was Jesus the Lord himself to have called this former persecutor in. Nevertheless, Paul, as an apostle, actively preached and even debated for Jesus the Christ in Jerusalem, even risking his life (Acts 9:28-29). So, the apostolic community sent him to Tarsus via Caesarea (Acts 9:30), perhaps for his safety, and later Barnabas looked for him in Tarsus, Paul’s hometown (Acts 11:22-26).

The canonical Scriptures are silent about how Matthew, who was hated and rejected by Jews, and likely so by the disciples, who were Jew, was received, though the challenges in Paul’s acceptance to the apostolic community in Jerusalem is written. Though Paul was feared by the apostolic community for his past persecutory authority, Matthew was not feared but rather despised for collecting taxes for Caesar.

So, an important question is – why Jesus brought a despised man, Matthew, and a feared man, Paul, to his “heard”, to build his Church?

In thinking and reflecting on this question, what comes to my mind is God’s desire to extend and share His covenant even to those who are outcast and despised for salvation (Isaiah 56:1-8). And God makes something new, like making a stream in the desert (Isaiah 43:19). So, God can choose some persons, who used to be hated, despised, and even considered as evil, to advance in His mission, which was initiated by Jesus the Son. God sure makes good out of evil for His mission. That is why conversion is essential.

Even though Matthew was seen as someone to be hated for what he used to do, even though Paul was seen as evil for what he used to do, by society, Jesus certainly saw these individuals worthy to follow and serve him. He must have been confident about their conversions, too.

It was not that Jesus called Matthew by chance. He know what was going through in depth of his heart, seeing the possibility of his conversion to turn his heart from tax collection to serving him for his Kingdom, as he knew Paul’s great zeal for God could be directed to the right way to build up his Church.

And, the disciples came to understand this by not complaining to Jesus about Matthew, and the apostles came to terms with this for being able to work with Paul to build the Church.

So, why did Jesus called a man, who was hated and rejected, Matthew the tax collector, and a man, who was feared, Paul the persecutor?

Being God, Jesus wanted to make something new (Isaiah 43:19) out of these men through conversions by extending his covenant to those who were rejected, making His house, the Church, a welcoming place, to those who turn away from evil and ungodly way in order to be with God (Isaiah 56:1-8). And Jesus called Matthew and Paul in, so that we can better understand the spirit of his teaching on extend our love beyond those whom we think “lovable” to the “unlovable” (i.e. Matthew 5:43-48).

So, what about us? What about you?

Do you think that you are not worthy to be in the Church because you feel you are rejected by others – even by some “faithful” churchy people? Is it because of your sinfulness?

If this is the case with you, think of Matthew and Paul. And remember that neither of these with respectively sinful backgrounds were necessarily welcomed by the community, because of their past. But, they were able to work together.

The bottom line, based on the cases of Matthew and Paul, is that they were called by Jesus directly and personally.

If Jesus has called you to follow, who in the world can reject you?  If Jesus has welcomed you already, then who can reject you (cf. Romans 15:7)?

And, the Catechism of the Catholic Church states:

At all times and in every race, anyone who fears God and does what is right has been acceptable to him. He has, however, willed to make men holy and save them, not as individuals without any bond or link between them, but rather to make them into a people who might acknowledge him and serve him in holiness. He therefore chose the Israelite race to be his own people and established a covenant with it. He gradually instructed this people. . . . All these things, however, happened as a preparation for and figure of that new and perfect covenant which was to be ratified in Christ . . . the New Covenant in his blood; he called together a race made up of Jews and Gentiles which would be one, not according to the flesh, but in the Spirit (781).

Nobody is unblemished. We all are imperfect with our own unique struggles with sins. Jesus does not wait until we all become perfect to call us in. He calls us as he wills on us, because he sees what is in us – our hearts’ deep desire for him and the gifts endowed by God through the Holy Spirit, therefore, our great potential, in the way that nobody else can recognize. And Matthew and Paul are just two great examples that Jesus demonstrated his desire to make holy unholy man.

Jesus continues to call people like Matthew and Paul even today, as the harvest plentiful but the workers are few (Matthew 9:37).

No comments:

Post a Comment