Sunday, April 17, 2022

Would the Empty Tomb be Enough Evidence to be Convinced of the Resurrection? Paschal Sunday

This is the day that the Lord has made! Let us rejoice and be glad! (Psalm 118:24, Responsorial Psalm refrain for Paschal Sunday) Praise and give thanks to God! (Isaiah 12:4-5) Alleluia!

But, on that early morning of the Resurrection, who was rejoicing?

According to the Gospel Readings of Paschal Vigil (Matthew 28:1-10(A); Mark 16:1-8 (B); Luke 24:1-12 (C) ) and Paschal Sunday (John 20;1-9), it all began with anxious confusion about the missing body of Jesus upon discovering that his tomb was empty.

Imagine – you visit the grave of a person dear to you, bringing some flowers. Then you discover that the grave is a hole in his grave, as if it were dug out. And you see the buried casket open and empty. Would you rejoice at the grave? Would you be glad that this person dear to you had resurrected? Perhaps, your first thought would be who dug the grave and stole the body.

It was just how the disciples started their journey to come to terms with the Resurrection of the Lord. They began with fearsome confusion about the empty tomb, wondering why the body of Jesus was missing there.

What does it tell you about the disciples, including Mary Magdalene?

Do you think that they really believed what Jesus had foretold about his suffering, death and resurrection?

Are we also like them, thinking that we think we believe but not really sure?

Matthew tells us that Jesus spoke to his disciples of the prospect of  his suffering, death, and resurrection four times before entering in his passion to death (Matthew 16:21-28:17:22-23; 20:17-19;26:1-2). Despite this, none of the disciples really believe the resurrection.  If they had believed, then, they would have rejoiced upon seeing the empty tomb.

In the Gospel Reading of Paschal Sunday (Resurrection Sunday)(John 20:1-9), we see chain reactions of confusion and fear being passed on from Mary Magdalene, who first discovered the tomb to be empty to Peter and the disciple whom Jesus loved, namely, John.  She thought that someone taken the body of Jesus out of the tomb (John 20:2). Having learned from Mary Magdalene about Jesus’ tomb to be empty, Peter and John raced to the tomb. John ran faster than Peter (John 20:4). Why? Because Peter’s heart was very heavy with the guilt of denying Jesus three times (John 18:15-18, 25-27), as foretold by Jesus during the Last Supper (John 13:36-38).

John only bent down and saw that the tomb as empty, left with Jesus’ burial cloths, but did not enter (John 20:5). On the other hand, Peter actually entered the empty tomb and saw the same (John 20:6).

This makes a contrast to the fact that John entered the courtyard of the high priest with Jesus, but Peter did not enter and stayed at the gate outside, on the night before Jesus’ death (John 18:15-16a). Then, John came out and spoke to the gatekeeper and let Peter in (John 18:16b). John was known to the high priest but Peter was not (John 18:15, 16).

Peter did not follow Jesus into the courtyard of the high priest, while John did when Jesus was taken there for the inquisition by Annas for Caiaphas the high priest, until John came to asked the gatekeeper to let him in (John 18:12-24). Peter entered the empty tomb of Jesus. But John did not enter (John 20:4-6).

Why was this?

Though the fact that John was an acquaintance to the high priest, Caiaphas (John 18:15-16) made it easier for him to enter the courtyard of the high priest, a true reason for Peter not to enter at first was the same reason why he could not run as fast as John in coming to the tomb of Jesus. It was because Peter was more with fear, compared to John. Peter was prone to fear even before feeling guilty by denying Jesus.


When Peter entered the empty tomb, he saw the burial cloths of Jesus were neatly placed (John 20:7). So, this indicates that the tomb of Jesus was not robbed. It shows that Mary Magdalene’s assumption of the body of Jesus to be taken away was less credible. If the body of Jesus was taken by a grave robber, then, the burial cloths would be scattered.

Then, finally John entered and saw the neatly placed burial cloths of Jesus, and believed that Jesus rose from the dead as foretold (John 20:8), though neither he nor Peter understood the scripture that foretold the Messiah had to rise from the dead (john 20:9).

Where in the Scripture prophesizes the resurrection of Jesus, the Messiah?

For you will not abandon my soul to Sheol, nor let your devout one see the pit.  You will show me the path to life, abounding joy in your presence, the delights at your right hand forever (Psalm 16:10-11).

Because of his anguish he shall see the light; because of his knowledge he shall be content; My servant, the just one, shall justify the many, their iniquity he shall bear. Therefore I will give him his portion among the many, and he shall divide the spoils with the mighty, Because he surrendered himself to death, was counted among the transgressors, Bore the sins of many, and interceded for the transgressors (Isaiah 53:11-12).

Though Peter was left in confusion and fear with his heavy heart of guilt for denying Jesus, John believed the resurrection without seeing the body of the risen Jesus.

So, nobody rejoiced in the morning of the resurrection. But, John believed that the empty tomb with Jesus’ burial cloths neatly folded and placed in the empty tomb, meant the resurrection.

In the Gospel Reading of the following Sunday (Second Sunday of Paschal Season)(John 20:19-31), contrast John in this Sunday’s Gospel (John 20:1-9) to Thomas, who did not believe in the resurrection even though he saw the body of risen Jesus – until he actually put his hand to the wound marks on the body of risen Jesus.

Jesus said:

Blessed are those who have not seen and have believed (John 20:29).

Though not yet rejoicing, at least John began to believe without seeing the body of risen Jesus.

Imagine that you were one of the disciples and followed him from Galilee to Jerusalem. You had heard Jesus foretelling his suffering, death, and resurrection multiple times. After the death of Jesus, after the burial of his body in the tomb, you came back to his tomb and discovered that it was empty, with his burial cloths neatly placed.

Would you believe that Jesus had actually resurrected as he foretold? Would the empty tomb with Jesus’ burial cloths neatly place be enough to be convinced that he rose from the dead? Or would you need more physical evidence to believe?

Whether you would be more like John or Thomas depends on your faith. And it determines whether you rejoice sooner or later.

No comments:

Post a Comment