Sunday, September 17, 2017

Not Cap on Our Forgiveness: Forgiving “Seventy-Seven” Times to Neutralize the Spiritual Poison of Lamech’s “Seventy-Seven-Fold” Avenge


 When we are offended, our first reaction is anger. Then, we may be tempted to avenge. It is how the limbic system, which is beneath the cerebral cortex of our brain, works. However, our lives shall not be dictated by the limbic system as we live according to the Word of God, empowered by the Holy Spirit and appreciating the boundless mercy of God. In order to understand what Jesus meant by forgiving "seventy-seven times", we must recognize the importance of God's mercy on us so that our responses to offenses against us will not be solely dictated by the limbic system and become vengeful. Putting reign on the limbic system not only through our rational thinking but also by the Word spoken by Jesus is also how we can overcome our narcissistic disposition, which prompts us to cling to anger and hatred, leading to increase our desire for retribution.


The scripture readings from Matthew 18:21-35, Sirach 27:30-28:7 , and Romans 14:7-9 can help us mediate on how we can keep our response to offenses against us from being dictated by the limbic system and how we can overcome our narcissistic tendency to avenge so that our response shall become forgiveness without a limit, reflecting the boundless mercy of God. 


                                                    *****

When Peter asked Jesus, how many times he should forgive someone who had offended him, Jesus’ answer was “not seven times but seventy-seven times”(Matthew 18:21-22).  What did Jesus meant by this ?

We must be careful not to read the scriptures as fundamentalists do whenever we come across certain numbers. We need to interpret numbers in the contexts so that we do not take them literally whenever they are not meant to. Usually, in the scriptures, numbers are used rather symbolically. We must understand what the numbers mean in the contexts of the sentences. 

In the case of “seventy-seven times” in the above statement of Jesus, it is understood that Jesus meant to teach the indefiniteness when we forgive someone. By saying, “not even seven times but seventy-seven times” to forgive, Jesus has told Peter that our forgiveness has no limit. We cannot put a cap in regard to how many times we should forgive.

Actually, the peculiarity of “seven” and “seventy-seven” in Jesus’ statement on forgiveness in Matthew 18:21-22 can be traced back to Genesis 4:15 and 23-24.

Cain said to God, “My punishment is more than I can bear. Today you are driving me from the land, and I will be hidden from your presence; I will be a restless wanderer on the earth, and whoever finds me will kill me”(Genesis 4:13-14). In reply, God said, “Not so; if anyone kills Cain, he will suffer vengeance seven times over” and put a mark on Cain so that no one who found him would kill him (Genesis 4:15).

God sure punished Cain for killing his brother, Abel. However, God not only spared Cain’s life but even protected him from any avenger so that no one would kill him, because He did not want sin of Cain to spread like an infectious disease. In other words, God’s special care for Cain was more to care for the world, keeping murder from spreading. God wanted Cain to be the last person, who had committed murder.

Alas, one of Cain’s offspring, Lamech, obviously failed to appreciate God’s special care not only for his ancestor, Cain, but for the world, as he became so proud of the ruthless vengeance he had afflicted on a person who had offended him:

Adah and Zillah, Listened to me; wives of Lamech, hear m words. I have killed a man for wounding me, and young man for injuring me. If Cain is avenged seven times, then Lamech seventy-seven times” (Genesis 4:23-24).

Now, it takes a bit of psychology to understand the problem of Lamech.

First, the way Lamech boasted to his wives about his avenge indicates that he thinks of himself greater than Cain.  He thought that his enemy would deserve seventy-seven-fold avenge if Cain’s enemy was entitled to sevenfold avenge. Second, he usurps God in regard to the power to retaliate a person who offends him. It was not Cain to avenge but God.  Even God so chooses, it will be sevenfold. However, Lamech proudly takes up the power of retaliation on his hands not sevenfold but seventy-seven-fold. This gives an impression as if he thought of himself greater than God in regard to the power of revenge. Obviously, Lamech exhibited a clinical symptom of grandiosity, which is typical of narcissistic personality disorder.

When Peter specifically asked if “seven times” to forgive (Matthew 18:21), perhaps, he was thinking of Genesis 4:15 to counter. In his reply to this, Jesus could have been thinking of Genesis 4:23-24 to indicate that forgiveness is to be done in a way to overcome the narcissistic problem of Lamech – to free the world from Lamech’s grandiosity of taking pride in retaliating even far more severely than God would.

Now, we can reflect on why Jesus wants us to forgive indefinitely by saying “seventy-seven times”.

Reading Matthew 18:21-35 in conjunction with Sirach 27:30-28:7 and Romans 14:7-9, as in the Liturgy of the Word for the 24th Sunday in Ordinary Time on Cycle A, with reference to Genesis 4:15 and 23-24,  we realize that Jesus’ intent in encouraging us to forgive without a cap is for us to overcome our narcissistic propensity.  Psychologically, the stronger our narcissistic tendency becomes, the more difficult it is to forgive but the stronger our anger and desire for vengeance can become.

The passage from Sirach reminds us that our tendency for vengeance reflects the sinfulness, which may become like Lamechs’ pride for his ability to revenge. To keep us from becoming like Lamech, Paul’s words in Romans 14 guide us to understand that we do not live and die for our own selves but for the Lord, who died and was raised for us.  It is because the bottom line of our difficulty to forgive is our narcissistic disposition, which gives a false notion that we live for ourselves.

The unforgiving servant in Matthew 18:21-35 was unable to forgive his fellow servant as his master did to him because his narcissism. Both this unforgiving servant and Lamech are on the same spectrum of narcissism. The unforgiving servant begged mercy to his master when he was in debt, and his debt was canceled as his master was merciful. Though he was to be as merciful as his master was to him, this servant was merciless to his fellow servant who owed him because he was so self-centered. Through the case of this unforgiving servant, the Gospel passage reminds us that a lack of gratitude for mercy is a symptom of narcissism and makes us become merciless to others. This problem may make us as arrogant and vengeful as Lamech, if we did not recognize our own narcissistic propensity and wake up to the truth that we are not living for ourselves but for the Lord.

Jesus wants us to be as merciful as the Father is merciful (Luke 6:36), and we must remember that retribution, if it has to be done, is solely for God to execute – not us (Deuteronomy 32:35). If we do not discipline our ego, then, we may become merciless like the unforgiving servant in Matthew 18:21-35 and arrogantly vengeful like Lamech in Genesis 4:23-24. That is why we need to remember, as Paul says in Romans 14:7-9, that we live for God, who is merciful and slow to anger and abundant in love (Psalm 103:8).
Leave vengeance to God and imitate God for His boundless mercy so that we can forgive those who offend us without a limit, as we overcome our narcissistic disposition by understanding that our life is not for ourselves but for God. That is why Jesus has taught to forgive “seventy-seven” times.


As we taste the boundless mercy of God, we grow in our gratitude to His abundant love. Through God’s mercy, we can overcome our narcissistic disposition. This is how we can neutralize the spiritual poison of Lamech’s arrogant and escalating vengeance. Otherwise, we may live in a samsara-like vicious endless cycle of Lamech’s vengeance until we burn our souls in our own anger and hatred.

No comments:

Post a Comment